The Elegance of Silver Overlay

Tiffany and Co Silver Overlay Glass TrivetSilver Overlay on Porcelain Teaset $1000Steuben Blank with Silver Overlay $295.00

Silver has been used to decorate bronze, copper, and earthenware for ages. Silver on glass, however, started to come into its own a little over a century ago.

In 1889 Oscar Pierre Erard of Birmingham, England developed an effective method of electroplating silver on glass and porcelain. Although beautiful on the outside, it shared an important shorcoming with its predecessors. The reverse side of the silver design, the side next to the glass would tarnish and turn dark. In clear plates, bowls, dishes and glasses this unsightly result was hardly condusive to a hearty appetite.

In 1893, an American from New Jersey by the name of John H. Scharling patented a method no less simple or beautiful than Erard's creation, but with a distinct advantage. The reverse side of the design was snow white and it stayed that way indefinitely. Like Erard's method, Sharling's designs utilized electroplating.

He shared his new process withall, both domestic and European. By 1895, the Czechs, Italians, French, English and Austrians were producing exciting glassware with sterling deposit and overlay. Not to be outdone, US makers began producing copiously.

From 1895 to the late 1920s, this elegant and exciting manifestation of the glassmaker and silversmith’s art garnered its own avid following, just short of becoming a decorative rage. Silver overlay and silver deposit were regarded as an exquisite, special gift or accent for that certain table or shelf. A few nice pieces of overlay were as evident in the genteel home as a piano in those days of refined, yet simple pleasures.

The Great Depression caused many of the glass companies to either go out of business or resort to specializing in cheaper, more affordable glassware.

The era of expensive sterling silver applied to glass was all but over and not may pieces can be found that were manufactured after the mid-1930s.

Today, most examples have disappeared into private collections and museums, but occasionally you can find that special piece for either yourself or an especially deserving and discriminating recipient.

Here are the answers to actual questions from customers and collectors:

Q: I’m a little confused. Isn’t silver overlay and silver deposit the same thing?
A: Yes and no. Originally because the manufacturers around the turn of the century used the “overlay” and “deposit” interchangeably, they were thought to be the same thing. Purists, however, argue that, because there are subtle differences in the manufacturing processes and the fact that ‘overlay’ is usually always ‘thick’ whereas ‘deposit’ is usually always ‘thin’, that a specific differentiation should be made. (I have a tendency to agree with the purists). There is a pamphlet masquerading as a book on silver ‘overlay’ which features on the cover, in color, a fine example of silver ‘deposit’. So I guess people can suit themselves as to the terminology.

Q: Is it a chore to keep clean and doesn’t it tarnish something fierce?
A: Actually, with our modern anti-tarnish silver creams, an initial cleaning is all that’s required. If you follow the directions, all you’ll need is a little touch up once a year (My favorite polish is Hagerty’s Silversmith’s Polish with R22 tarnish preventative in the blue plastic bottle, and no, I don’t own stock in the company!) Later, say to 1925 to 1935, domestically made silver overlay pieces had a rhodium treatment at the factory and need no polishing whatsoever.

Q: I love the looks of silver overlay and deposit but how can I get started? What’s good and what’s no so good?
A: As with most art, let your own sense of taste be your guide. Pick out a piece that you like and that you can display in a special place or use for special occasions or guests. I f you can find a massed display of silver on glass, it makes choosing much easier because then you don’t have to scour the entire state to find a half dozen examples.

Q: I have a faorite aunt who is crazy about Venetian glass and I wonder if the Italians ever made any Venetian glass with silver?
A: You can find some nice examples of silver deposit on Venetian glass; usually in the form of decanter sets or small to medium sized vases. They will be from Murano, however, which is a sister island in the Venetian lagoon. Venice moved its legendary glassworks to Murano at the end of the thirteenth century as a fire prevention measure and also to hide their manufacturing secrets from prying eyes.

Q: I love Czechoslovakian art glass but can’t remember seeing any with silver decorations. Have they made any silver deposit or overlay?
A: I could name a dozen famous deceased Czech artisans who are at this moment turning over in their graves at this question. The answer is Yes, Yes, and Yes! Some of the most magnificent silver work on glass is the late nineteenth and twentieth century Czech. The problem is that over the years the intricate silver designs have tarnished and now appear as black or copper colored paint. All they need is a thorough and careful cleaning to release the hidden beauty. I once sold a cobalt vase made by a renowned Czech artist of generations past. It was represented to me by an East Coast dealer as being ”copper overlay deposit” (whatever that is). When I returned to Washington, five minutes with a sponge and polish resulted in an amazing transformation. I had personally turned copper into silver! Imagine that.

Q: I have a couple of nice serving plates with silver overlay and would like to use them for special occasions. But I’m scared I’ll ruin them. What should I do?
A: Nothing enhances a sit down dinner like elegant serving plates and platters. Feel free to use them if you follow these simple rules:

1. Never cut anything on the plate. Pre slice meats or breads beforehand.
2. Never serve eggs or egg products. The high sulfur content wreaks havoc.
3. Never, never use the dishwasher! Wash and rinse by hand in warm water and mild detergent.
4. Always rinse off silver polish. Digestion is not aided by ingesting silver polish.

Q: I love the looks of silver overlay and deposit and would like to start a collection. Should I start now and are prices likely to go up or down?
A: Collecting art as an investment is always a dicey proposition and should be the province of the very rich or the very knowledgeable. Buy what you like personally and let the chips fall where they may. Prices in the more populous areas of the country are already skyrocketing on silver deposit and overlay. My guess is, in as little as a year from now, the prices we’re paying in the Northwest today will seem cheap indeed by comparison.

Q: I have inherited an extremely delicate piece of Florentine glass with somewhat worn and thin silver deposit. I would like to clean the silver but I’m afraid a commercial silver cleaner would be too abrasive. I don’t want the silver design to disappear because it is breathtaking. What can I do?
A: Here is my pet recipe for a super mild silver cleaner:
1 teaspoon cigarette ashes
1/8 teaspoon corn starch or flour
3/4 teaspoon water (or more)
1/8 teaspoon Hagerty’s (blue bottle) anti tarnish paste.
Mix into a thin paste, adding more water if necessary. Apply thinly to silver- do not rub!- and let dry. After drying, polish ever so gently with a terry towel. Repeat as many times as needed.

Q: Why are some of the silver patterns the same on the two different brands of glassware (i.e., Heisey or Fostoria)?
A:Most glassmakers did not have their own silver department. Fostoria was a notable exception. Fostoria also had silver work done by outside silversmiths and did indeed do a limited amount of silver work for other glass makers in their own shop. Although a few of the silver companies survive to this day, many also fell by the wayside during the Great Depression or shortly thereafter.

Cribska Bohemian Arts & Crafts Silver Overlay $375.00Silver Deposit on Czech Amethyst Glass Box $95.00

Shop for Silver Overlay and 16,500 other antiques on our website: